Skip to content
24/7 support · call, text or WhatsApp +1 (816) 338-9049 Call Text WhatsApp
Investing and trading involve risk. The value of your investments can go down as well as up, and you may get back less than you put in.
A small green seedling growing in dark soil

Fixed-term accounts or managed portfolios: how to choose

One pays a rate you can see from the start. The other follows the markets. Here is how to decide which suits your money and your patience.

All insights

Two of our products look similar from the outside: you put money in, it works for a period, and you take it out. They behave very differently when markets move. Choosing between them comes down to how much certainty you need and how much movement you can live with.

This guide sets the two side by side, works through what each could do with the same amount of money, covers the third option in between, and ends with the questions that make the decision easier.

Fixed-term accounts: a rate set on day one

A fixed-term account pays a yearly rate that is agreed when the account opens. On our platform there are three terms: 3 months at 4.20% a year, 6 months at 4.30% a year, and 12 months at 5.00% a year. The rate is fixed on the day the account opens. A change in rates later does not change the rate on your account.

At the end of the term you get your money back, plus the interest it earned. The return is predictable while the term runs. As a simple example, $5,000 in the 12 months account at 5.00% a year earns $250 over the year ($5,000 x 5.00%), so it returns $5,250 at the end of the term, provided you leave it to maturity. Interest is worked out on an actual/365 day count.

You can leave a fixed-term account early. You get your money back, plus interest at the Daily plan rate (3.60% a year) for the time it was in. That is the trade: the fixed rate is the reward for leaving it alone.

Fixed-term accounts suit money you will not need until the term ends, and a person who would rather have a known number than a possible bigger one.

Managed portfolios: exposure to the markets

A managed portfolio spreads your money across shares, bonds and cash in a mix chosen for a risk level. We invest and rebalance your portfolio for you. Rebalancing brings the mix back to its targets as markets move. Ours come in three levels:

  • Conservative: 20% shares, 70% bonds, 10% cash.
  • Balanced: 50% shares, 45% bonds, 5% cash.
  • Growth: 80% shares, 20% bonds.

The management fee is 0.25% a year. On $5,000 that is $12.50 a year. There is no fixed return. The value moves with the markets in the mix, which means it can go down as well as up.

Shares are the part of the mix that moves most. They can rise and fall sharply from one year to the next. Bonds usually move less, and cash barely moves at all, which is why the Conservative mix, with a small share of shares, is meant to be the calmest and the Growth mix, with 80% in shares, the most volatile. Rebalancing brings the mix back to its targets as markets move, so a level keeps the risk it was chosen for.

What the published projections show

Our published projections show what each mix could do over 10 years, with a middle case and a range around it. They are yearly rates compounded, before the management fee. Here is what $5,000 would become in each case.

Level Low case Middle case High case
Conservative 1.0% a year: about $5,523 3.5% a year: about $7,053 5.5% a year: about $8,541
Balanced 0.5% a year: about $5,256 5.0% a year: about $8,144 8.0% a year: about $10,795
Growth 0.0% a year: about $5,000 6.5% a year: about $9,386 10.5% a year: about $13,570

A hypothetical range for illustration, not a promise. Returns can be negative. A bad decade can do worse than the low case, and the table does not show it. The gap between the low and the high case is the honest message: the higher the middle number, the wider the range of outcomes around it.

Managed portfolios suit money you can leave invested for years, where you want the potential of markets rather than a set rate, and where you can accept a value that moves.

Short-cycle plans, for money that needs to stay flexible

There is a third option worth knowing. The Daily plan pays every day at 3.60% a year, and money can leave after 7 days. The Weekly plan pays every week at 3.90% a year, and money can leave after 30 days. The rate can change for new deposits; money already in keeps its rate until it leaves.

These sit between the two: a known rate and much easier access, at a lower rate than the longer fixed terms.

Comparing the three

Fixed-term account Short-cycle plan Managed portfolio
What you get A rate fixed on the day you open A rate that pays every day or every week Whatever the markets in the mix deliver
Rate or return 4.20% a year to 5.00% a year 3.60% a year and 3.90% a year No fixed return; projections only
Can the value fall? Not in dollars, provided we pay Not in dollars, provided we pay Yes, sometimes sharply
Access At maturity, or early at the Daily plan rate. No top-ups or part withdrawals After 7 or 30 days. You can add to it Add or take money out at any time; opening and leaving are free
Cost No management fee No management fee 0.25% a year

Questions that make the choice easier

When will I need the money? If the answer is within a year, a fixed-term account or a short-cycle plan fits better than a managed portfolio. If you can leave the money for five years or more, the managed portfolios have time to work.

How would I feel if the value fell by 20%? Managed portfolios can produce falls like that in a bad period. If the answer is "I would sell", the fixed-rate options are probably the better fit, even if the projected return is lower.

What am I comparing? A fixed rate of 4.30% a year is certain. A projected 5.0% a year is a middle case with a range around it. Comparing them as if they were the same number is a common mistake.

What does it cost? The managed portfolios charge 0.25% a year. The fixed-term and short-cycle accounts don't have a management fee; the rate you see is the rate you get.

What happens if rates change? Fixed-term money keeps its rate until maturity. Short-cycle money keeps its rate until it leaves, but new deposits get the rate of the day. Managed portfolio returns are not tied to a rate at all.

A mix is normal

Most people don't choose one and only one. It is common to hold a fixed-term account for known future costs, a short-cycle plan for money that might be needed soon, and a managed portfolio for money that is genuinely long term.

What matters is that each pot has a job, and that the product matches the job. A fixed-term account holding your emergency fund can be a poor fit if you need the money in a hurry. A managed portfolio holding next year's tax payment is a poor fit too.

The risks, stated plainly

Fixed-term accounts are not risk-free: you are relying on us to pay, and leaving early reduces the interest you receive. Managed portfolios carry market risk. Their value can fall, sometimes sharply, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Projections are illustrations, not forecasts.

If you are unsure which product suits you, speak to an independent adviser. We don't give personal investment advice, and this article is general information, not a recommendation.

In short

  • A fixed-term account pays a rate fixed on the day it opens, from 4.20% a year for 3 months to 5.00% a year for 12 months. Leaving early pays the Daily plan rate for the time the money was in.
  • A managed portfolio has no fixed return. Its value follows the markets in its mix, it can fall, and it costs 0.25% a year.
  • Short-cycle plans sit between the two, with a known rate and easier access.
  • Match the product to the job: known costs soon belong in fixed rates, long-term money can take market movement.
  • Projections are illustrations of a range, not promises.

Ready to put it into practice?

Open an account to follow traders, choose a plan or practise first with a demo balance.